How to Decide Between Two PhD Offers
Two funded offers in hand is a good problem — and a real one. This guide shows how to decide between two PhD offers without guessing: compare funding, supervisor, lab, location and exit options on one scorecard, then choose and decline well.
On this page
- The answer in short
- How to decide between two PhD offers: the six questions that matter
- Funding: read the offer letter line by line
- The supervisor and the lab
- The April 15 rule — and other deadlines
- The scorecard
- Common mistakes
- Your checklist
- What to do next
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources checked
The answer in short
Choosing between two funded PhD offers comes down to six questions: what does the funding cover and for how long; who is the supervisor and what is the lab like; what will you work on; where will you live and what will it cost; what happens if the project or the relationship goes wrong; and what does each option do for the career you want in five years? Get every answer in writing — a verbal promise is not an offer; an offer letter is the only document that counts. In the United States, most funded offers are covered by the Council of Graduate Schools’ April 15 Resolution: you are under no obligation to answer before 15 April. Use that time: visit both places if you can, talk to current students without the professor present, and score both offers on the same sheet. Then choose, tell the other programme promptly, politely, and stop second-guessing.
How to decide between two PhD offers: the six questions that matter
Funding. What is covered, for how long, and on what conditions? Compare tuition, stipend, health insurance, travel, fees — and the years guaranteed. A five-year guarantee beats a one-year offer with a promise of renewal. Ask about the summer, and whether funding depends on teaching.
Supervisor. You will spend four to six years working for this person. Read their recent papers, check how long their students take to finish, and ask current students: does the supervisor meet students regularly, and do students leave the group on good terms? A brilliant researcher who never meets students is a bad supervisor.
Project. Is the project defined, funded and publishable — or a vague idea with no money attached? Ask what the first year’s work would actually be, and what a successful thesis from this group looks like.
Place. Where will you live, what does it cost, and can you live on the stipend there? A stipend comfortable in one city is tight in another. Check rent, not just the stipend figure.
Exit options. What happens if the project fails, the funding ends, or the relationship breaks down? Can you change supervisor, change group, or leave with a master’s? Programmes with a clear answer are safer.
Career. Where do this group’s graduates go — academia, industry, government, or out of research entirely? The destination list is the most honest advertisement.
Funding: read the offer letter line by line
The offer letter is the whole deal; everything else is conversation. Read it line by line and note what is missing. Does it state the stipend, the payment schedule, and the years guaranteed? Does it cover tuition fully? Is health insurance included, and does it cover dependants? Is there a teaching requirement, and how many hours? Is there a summer stipend, or does funding stop in June? Is it a fellowship, a teaching or a research assistantship — and can it change? If anything is unclear, ask in writing and keep the reply. If an offer is unfunded or only partly funded, be honest about the debt: a PhD that leaves you in debt is a different decision, and the guide on choosing between a PhD and a job after MSc covers it.
The supervisor and the lab
The supervisor matters more than the university name. A PhD is an apprenticeship: your supervisor trains you, funds you, writes your references and opens doors — or not. Before you decide, do three things. First, read the group’s last three years of papers and note where the first authors went. Second, email two current students and one recent graduate, and ask what a normal week looks like, how often the supervisor meets students, and how long students take. Third, visit if you can, and watch the lab: do people talk, is anyone there at midnight, does the supervisor know the students’ names? Trust what you see over what you are told. A lab where students finish in five years and leave on good terms beats a famous name where they take seven.
The April 15 rule — and other deadlines
If your offers are from the United States, know the April 15 rule. The Council of Graduate Schools’ April 15 Resolution is an agreement among signatory schools: a student offered full tuition support, a fellowship, a traineeship or an assistantship for the fall term is under no obligation to respond before 15 April, and an acceptance given before 15 April can be withdrawn in writing up to that date. After 15 April, an acceptance commits you to inform the first programme in writing before accepting another. The resolution applies only to offers of financial support, not admission alone, and not all programmes are signatories — check whether each of yours is one, and read the exact deadline in your offer letter. Outside the United States the rules differ: UK and European offers often carry their own deadlines, sometimes only two to four weeks, and funded places can be reallocated. Read every deadline in every letter, put them in a calendar, and ask for more time in writing — programmes expect to be asked.
The scorecard
Score both offers one to five on the six questions above: funding, supervisor, project, place, exit options, career. Weight the questions by what matters to you — for academia, the supervisor and the publication record; for industry, the skills and the location. Add the scores, then ignore the total for a day and ask which offer you would regret turning down. If the scorecard and your gut disagree, find out why — usually one is using information the other missed, such as a supervisor’s reputation or a funding condition. Talk it through with a mentor, not with the programmes themselves. And remember: there is rarely a wrong choice between two funded offers — the wrong choice is the one made without reading the letters.
Common mistakes
- Choosing the bigger name. The supervisor and the lab matter more than the brand.
- Comparing stipends without comparing costs. Rent decides what a stipend is worth.
- Accepting a verbal promise. Only the offer letter counts — get it in writing.
- Deciding under pressure. The April 15 rule exists so you do not have to rush.
- Ignoring exit options. Ask what happens if the project or the relationship fails.
- Ghosting the programme you decline. A polite, prompt decline keeps a door open.
Your checklist
- ☐ Both offer letters read line by line; gaps listed
- ☐ Funding compared: amount, years, tuition, insurance, teaching, summer
- ☐ Supervisor checked: recent papers, completion times, current students contacted
- ☐ Cost of living checked for both cities — rent first
- ☐ Exit options asked: change of supervisor or group, master’s exit
- ☐ Graduate destinations checked for both groups
- ☐ Every deadline in a calendar; April 15 rule confirmed
- ☐ Decision made on a scorecard, not a phone call
What to do next
Write to both programmes with questions the letters left unanswered, and keep the replies. Visit if you can, and talk to current students without the professor. Score both offers, sleep on it, then accept one and decline the other in writing — promptly, politely, and with thanks. Read the guide on choosing between a PhD and a job after MSc if the funded-versus-unfunded question is still open, and check the Research Guides hub and the funded PhD opportunities for current calls. Once you have decided, stop comparing. A PhD is long; energy spent second-guessing is energy the work needs.
Frequently asked questions
Can I accept one offer and change my mind later?
In the United States, yes — up to 15 April, under the April 15 Resolution, if the offer is funded and at a signatory institution: you can withdraw an acceptance in writing through 15 April. After 15 April, you must inform the first programme in writing before accepting another. Outside the US, the rules depend on the offer letter — read it, and ask the programme in writing.
Should I tell a programme I have another offer?
Yes, politely and only when it is true. Programmes expect it, and it can help: a department may improve funding, arrange a visit, or speed up a decision. Never invent a competing offer — it is a small world.
What if one offer is funded and the other is not?
Treat them as different decisions, not two versions of the same one. An unfunded PhD means debt, part-time work, or family support for four to six years. Unless you have a clear, affordable plan for the money, the funded offer is usually the right choice — the guide on choosing between a PhD and a job after MSc works through the maths.
Sources checked
- Council of Graduate Schools, April 15 Resolution FAQ — https://cgsnet.org/resources/for-current-prospective-graduate-students/april-15-resolution/april-15-resolution-faq — checked 19 November 2026 (resolution applies to offers of full tuition support, a graduate fellowship, traineeship or assistantship for fall-term starts at signatory institutions; students under no obligation to respond before 15 April; acceptance before 15 April can be withdrawn in writing through 15 April; after 15 April, inform the first programme in writing before accepting another; not all programmes are signatories; resolution renewed August 2026).
- The six questions, the scorecard, the supervisor checks and the decline advice are editorial guidance from IISER Connect, not rules stated by any university.
- Every deadline differs by programme: readers must read their own offer letters and confirm whether each programme is a signatory to the April 15 Resolution.